Cash for Silver in Fayetteville, AR
Fayetteville’s trusted silver buyer since 2011 — right on College Ave at Fiesta Square. Spot-rate pricing on coins, bars, flatware & jewelry. Walk out with cash the same visit.
We buy silver coins, sterling silver, bullion bars, and silver jewelry. No appointment, no pressure, no runaround. Hundreds of Northwest Arkansas customers have sold to us.
What Silver We Buy in Fayetteville
Not sure if we will buy it? Bring it in. We evaluate everything for free with zero obligation.
Silver Coins
- •American Silver Eagle (1 oz)
- •Morgan & Peace silver dollars
- •Pre-1965 junk silver (dimes, quarters, halves)
- •Canadian Maple Leaf silver coins
- •Mexican Libertad & world silver coins
- •Proof sets and commemoratives
Silver Bars & Bullion
- •Engelhard silver bars (any size)
- •PAMP Suisse silver bars
- •Silver rounds (1 oz and larger)
- •100 oz silver bars
- •Silver ingots and cast bars
- •Generic private mint rounds
Sterling Silver & Jewelry
- •Sterling silver flatware & silverware sets
- •Silver tea sets and serving pieces
- •Sterling silver rings, necklaces, bracelets
- •Antique and estate silver pieces
- •Silver candlesticks and decorative items
- •Scrap sterling and damaged silver items
Have something not on this list? Bring it anyway. If it contains silver, we can evaluate it. 15 years in Northwest Arkansas means we have seen nearly everything.
How It Works
Simple. Transparent. Same-day payment.
Walk In — No Appointment
Come to our Fayetteville location at 3065 N College Ave in Fiesta Square, by the AT&T store. Bring whatever silver you have — coins, flatware, bars, or jewelry.
Free On-the-Spot Evaluation
We weigh your silver on a certified scale, verify the purity, and check the current live spot price. We walk you through every step and explain exactly how we arrived at your offer.
Walk Out With Cash
Accept our offer and get paid immediately — cash or check. If you decide not to sell, there is no fee and no obligation. We return your items on the spot.
Why Fayetteville Sells Silver Here — Not Somewhere Else
There are pawn shops, mail-in buyers, and coin dealers in the area. Here is why Fayetteville customers choose us.
Live Spot-Rate Pricing
Silver prices move daily. We price every offer against live market spot rates — not a fixed house rate set last week. You get a real-time fair market price on every visit.
vs. Pawn Shops on College Ave
Pawn shops need margin to lend and resell. They low-ball because they have to. We are a dedicated precious metals buyer — our only business is paying you fairly for the metal value.
Transparent, Visible Process
We show you the scale reading, the spot price we are using, and how we calculated the offer. Every step is visible. No mystery, no secret formula, no guessing.
Part of the Fayetteville Community
We have been at 3065 N College Ave for over a decade — the same location, the same team. University of Arkansas faculty and longtime Fayetteville families have all sold to us. We live here too.
I had a silverware set from my grandmother that had been in a box for twenty years. The team in Fayetteville weighed everything in front of me, showed me the spot price, and explained the math. I walked out with more than I expected and felt completely informed about the whole process.
— Fayetteville customer, 2024
Sterling silver flatware set — Fiesta Square location
Our Fayetteville Location
In Fiesta Square on N College Avenue — easy to find, free parking, walk-ins welcome.
Fayetteville
3065 N College Avenue
Fayetteville, AR 72703
In Fiesta Square, by the AT&T store
Hours
Monday – Friday: 10am – 6pm
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed
Phone
(479) 301-2438
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
More Ways to Sell in Fayetteville
Sell Gold & Silver
Our main gold and silver buying page — all metals, all forms, both locations.
Sell Your Silver (All Locations)
Detailed silver buying guide for both our Fayetteville and Siloam Springs locations.
Cash for Gold — Fayetteville
Selling gold in Fayetteville? See our gold buying services at the Fiesta Square location.
Ready to Sell Your Silver in Fayetteville?
Walk in today. Free evaluation. Same-day payment. No appointment needed.
3065 N College Ave, Fayetteville, AR 72703 · Open Mon–Fri 10am–6pm